Ad Astra Per Aspera
Latin for “To the Stars Through Difficulty” – the State motto of Kansas (my home state).
I decided I should more clearly define my rating scale used here on my blog for all my reviews. I actually composed most of what follows for my GoodReads profile back when I joined that site in 2008. GoodReads rating stars include a very brief description of what they mean when you hover over them with your mouse (one star = ‘didn’t like it’; two stars = ‘it was okay’; three stars = ‘liked it’; four stars = ‘really liked it’; and, five stars = ‘it was amazing’).
My difficulty arises from writing a review, not from applying a rating to what ever it is I am reviewing. The following contains my completely subjective opinion on a five star scale for rating all kinds of things – books, movies, products, services, etc.
So on to the stars!
No Star (or One Star if required to select a minimum): A one star rating from me means I disliked and in some cases loathed the item before me. I would even go so far to equate my one star to no stars, but as I must assign at least a single star, this is my zero.
Two Stars: Two stars usually means I felt unmoved by the book or movie. Roughly equivalent to a “Fair” or “Okay” recommendation. Not something I would probably re-read or re-watch.
Three Stars: My three star rating represents the average to above average range, usually associated with “Good” for me. I might recommend the work and re-visit it, if no other new potential four or five star material was at hand.
Four Stars: When I recommend something to a friend, or even a total stranger, it invariably comes from something in this rating category. I often re-read works I give a four star rating to, because I enjoy reliving the adventure and the character struggles.
Five Stars: For items I just can’t get enough of. Books I’ve read countless times or movies I’ve watched so many times I know all the dialogue and scenes so well I’m wrenched when the networks edit them “to fit in the time allotted.” In the case of a book, a five star rating means I’ve become so emotionally attached to the characters that I’m devastated when I finish the book because I’m not in communion with them any longer. It also means I won’t be able to read a book for a day or two to recover emotionally.
DNF: Did Not Finish. Pretty self-explanatory. It just wasn’t my thing or it was affecting my mood or outlook on life negatively and I just needed it to stop.
* * *
I strive to be a five star Scrooge. Something must be truly gifted, the very pinnacle of excellence, before I will bestow my highest honor upon it. I am a bit more lenient with a four star rating, often waffling between three and four stars on most of what I consume. I have friends and the Internet to thank for that last bit, since many other people have already expressed their opinions about just about anything and everything, so I can weed out the obvious chaff.
I also try to let my brain rest for a day or two before applying a rating and composing a review. Unless, of course, I couldn’t stomach it, then I’m quick to verbalize my loathing. All of this only applies in my universe, the one between my ears, so please take my opinions with a grain of salt.
205 thoughts on “Two Stars or Not Two Stars? That is the Rating Question”
You summarized almost exactly how I rate books. I haven’t put ratings on reviews at my own blog so far, but I use more or less the same scale as you do on GoodReads.
I am honored to be in such fine company. Thanks for stopping by and commenting on my post. I love your new blog!
Thanks! It’s been a learning curve for me. I’ve always just been about content, and to now suddenly also have to do all the rest… it’s a challenge – but a fun one!
Very nice rating system! God bless!
Comments are closed.